LP SmartSide: A Smart Choice for Siding or a Tough Call?
Are you looking for a siding that combines durability with a natural wood look?
Are you wondering if LP SmartSide can withstand Northeast Wisconsin’s challenging weather?
Many homeowners are considering LP SmartSide for its aesthetic appeal and long-lasting performance.
In this post, we’ll dive into the pros and cons of LP SmartSide siding, compare it with other popular options, and explore whether it’s the right choice for your home.
By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of how this siding installation performs and whether it’s worth the investment.
What Are the Pros and Cons of LP SmartSide?
LP SmartSide siding has made a name for itself with its durability, aesthetic appeal, and eco-friendly benefits.
But like any siding option, it comes with its pros and cons.
Let’s dive into the key advantages and disadvantages to help you determine if this is the right choice for your home in Northeast Wisconsin.
Pros of LP SmartSide Siding
Durability and Impact Resistance
When it comes to durability, LP SmartSide siding stands out due to its engineered wood construction.
It’s designed to endure the harsh winters and heavy winds that are common in Northeast Wisconsin.
- Resistant to impacts: Whether it’s debris, hail, or harsh weather, LP SmartSide handles the elements better than materials like vinyl siding or traditional wood siding.
- Zinc borate treatment: This innovative treatment makes the siding resistant to termite damage, fungal decay, and rot, extending its lifespan significantly.
Versatile Aesthetic Options
For homeowners seeking a natural look, LP SmartSide offers the beauty of wood without the downsides.
- Natural wood appearance: It replicates the look of authentic wood, offering textures like lap siding and shingles that can enhance your home’s exterior.
- Customizable: LP SmartSide comes in various custom color options and can be painted or stained to match your design preferences.
- Prefinished and pre-primed: You can choose between prefinished siding for immediate curb appeal or pre-primed options for greater flexibility.
Lightweight and Easy Installation
Unlike fiber cement siding, LP SmartSide is much lighter, making the installation process easier and more efficient.
- Saves labor costs: The reduced weight speeds up installation, which can lower labor costs.
- DIY-friendly: It’s also an appealing option for homeowners who prefer to take on installation projects themselves.
Environmentally Friendly
Eco-conscious homeowners will appreciate the sustainable aspects of LP SmartSide siding.
- Renewable resources: It’s made from engineered wood strands and wood fibers, which come from sustainable forests.
- Low environmental impact: The manufacturing process uses less energy than other siding materials, making it a greener choice compared to fiber cement or steel siding.
Follow the link to discover more benefits of using LP SmartSide siding for your home.
Cons of LP SmartSide Siding
Vulnerability to Moisture
While LP SmartSide is designed to be durable, it does have one key weakness: moisture.
- Potential for moisture damage: If the siding is not properly installed, moisture can seep into cut edges, leading to swelling or warping over time.
- Professional installation recommended: In areas like Northeast Wisconsin, where snow and rain are frequent, it’s important to ensure the siding is installed by a siding professional to prevent moisture intrusion.
Higher Initial Cost
Though it offers long-term value, LP SmartSide comes with a higher initial cost compared to other options like vinyl siding.
- Cost per square foot: You can expect to pay between $10 to $15 per square foot, including material and installation costs.
- Investment pays off: While the upfront cost is higher, the durability and less maintenance required over time can make it a smart financial choice.
Requires Regular Maintenance
If you opt for non-prefinished LP SmartSide, you’ll need to commit to repainting or staining every 10–15 years to keep it looking its best.
- Maintenance tasks: Regular upkeep includes checking and repainting trim boards, sealing cut edges, and touching up areas exposed to the elements.
- Essential to prevent damage: Without proper care, LP SmartSide can be susceptible to moisture intrusion, which could lead to expensive repairs down the road.
LP SmartSide vs. Other Siding Materials

Choosing the right siding for your home in Northeast Wisconsin means comparing LP SmartSide with other popular options like vinyl, fiber cement, and traditional wood siding.
Each material offers its own set of benefits and drawbacks, and it’s important to understand how LP SmartSide stacks up in terms of performance, appearance, and cost.
LP SmartSide vs. Vinyl Siding
LP SmartSide siding and vinyl siding both have their advantages, but they serve different needs for homeowners.
- Durability: LP SmartSide is more resistant to impacts and weather compared to vinyl, which can become brittle in cold weather.
- Appearance: While vinyl siding tends to have a more artificial look, LP SmartSide mimics the texture and natural beauty of wood siding, offering a more authentic aesthetic.
- Maintenance: Vinyl siding requires less upkeep, while LP SmartSide needs occasional painting or staining, especially in high-moisture climates like Northeast Wisconsin.
LP SmartSide vs. Fiber Cement Siding
When comparing LP SmartSide siding to fiber cement siding, homeowners often look at weight, installation, and moisture resistance.
- Weight and Installation: LP SmartSide is lighter and easier to handle during the installation process, reducing labor time and costs. In contrast, fiber cement siding, like James Hardie siding, is heavier and more difficult to install.
- Fire Resistance: Fiber cement has better fire resistance, making it a popular choice in regions prone to wildfires. However, LP SmartSide performs well in most climates, provided it is installed correctly.
- Moisture Concerns: While fiber cement naturally resists moisture, LP SmartSide requires careful sealing of cut edges to avoid water infiltration.
Follow the link to view an in-depth comparison of fiber cement James Hardie vs. LP SmartSide.
LP SmartSide vs. Traditional Wood Siding
For those who want the look of traditional wood siding but without the maintenance, LP SmartSide offers a modern solution.
- Low Maintenance: Unlike wood siding, LP SmartSide resists fungal decay, rot, and termite damage thanks to its treatment with zinc borate.
- Aesthetic: LP SmartSide provides the same natural wood appearance as traditional siding but with the added benefits of being less prone to pest infestation and weather-related wear.
- Cost: While LP SmartSide has a higher upfront cost than vinyl siding, it is more affordable than high-end wood materials like cedar and offers a better long-term value.
Follow the link to view an in-depth comparison of LP SmartSide vs. wood siding.
Cost of LP SmartSide Siding
Material and Installation Costs
The cost of LP SmartSide siding depends on factors such as the style of siding you choose and your location in Northeast Wisconsin.
Here’s a breakdown of typical costs:
- Price per square foot installed: Ranges from $10 to $15 per square foot, depending on the specific product and finish.
- Factors that influence cost:
- The style of siding, such as lap siding or panel siding.
- Whether you choose prefinished or non-prefinished siding, with prefinished options generally costing more upfront.
- Regional labor costs and the complexity of your home’s architecture can impact overall installation pricing.
Long-Term Value
While the upfront cost of LP SmartSide siding may be higher than vinyl siding, the long-term value it offers can make it a worthwhile investment:
- Durability: LP SmartSide is built to withstand harsh weather and resist termite damage and fungal decay, meaning fewer repairs over time.
- Low maintenance: Although occasional repainting or staining may be required (especially for non-prefinished siding), the overall maintenance needs are lower than traditional wood siding.
- Longevity: With proper care, LP SmartSide can last for decades, reducing the frequency of replacements.
- Customization options: The ability to paint or stain LP SmartSide offers homeowners flexibility in updating their home’s curb appeal over time.
Is LP SmartSide the Right Choice for Your Home?
When deciding whether LP SmartSide siding is the best fit for your home in Northeast Wisconsin, it’s important to consider the region’s climate and how the siding will perform over time.
The combination of customization options and long-lasting durability makes LP SmartSide a popular choice, but understanding its strengths in your local context is key.
Climate and Weather Considerations
Northeast Wisconsin experiences a wide range of weather, from freezing winters to humid summers.
This makes it essential to choose a siding that can handle the local climate.
- Impact resistance: LP SmartSide offers excellent protection against high winds, snow, and hail, making it well-suited for the region’s extreme weather conditions.
- Moisture resistance: Proper installation and sealing of cut edges are critical to prevent moisture damage, especially with the heavy snowfall and rain that are common in this area. When installed by professional siding contractors, LP SmartSide can effectively resist moisture.
- Durability: The engineered wood composition, treated with zinc borate, helps prevent termite damage, fungal decay, and rot, making LP SmartSide more durable in both wet and cold climates than traditional wood siding.
Customization and Design Options
For homeowners who want to give their homes a unique look, LP SmartSide siding offers a variety of styles and finishes that provide both flexibility and curb appeal.
- Versatile styles: LP SmartSide comes in multiple styles, including lap siding, panel siding, and shingles, allowing you to match it with modern, traditional, or farmhouse designs.
- Custom colors: Whether you opt for a prefinished or non-prefinished option, LP SmartSide allows you to choose from a range of custom colors that fit your design vision.
- Low maintenance: Unlike wood siding, which requires frequent upkeep, LP SmartSide maintains its appearance with far less effort. Occasional repainting or staining is required for non-prefinished versions, but it lasts much longer than fiber cement siding in harsh conditions.
Urban Exteriors: Your Trusted Partner for LP SmartSide Installation
LP SmartSide offers a unique combination of durability, design flexibility, and long-term value, making it a great choice for homeowners in Northeast Wisconsin.
With its ability to withstand extreme weather, resist moisture, and provide a beautiful wood-like appearance, it’s an option that can boost both your home’s protection and curb appeal.
Choosing the right siding is only part of the equation.
To get the most out of your investment, you need a professional installation that ensures your LP SmartSide is properly fitted, sealed, and ready to perform in any condition.
That’s where Urban Exteriors comes in.
Our team of experts is here to ensure your siding project goes smoothly from start to finish.
If you’re ready to upgrade your home’s exterior, fill out our contact form today or give us a call to get started!