Board and Batten Siding vs. Lap Siding: Which is the Better Choice?

Key Points

  • Board and batten siding enhances a home’s vertical aesthetics, making it appear taller and more stately, while lap siding extends the visual breadth of a property, contributing to a streamlined look.
  • Choosing the right siding material impacts not only the appearance but also the durability and maintenance needs of your home, with options like fiber cement offering excellent durability and minimal upkeep.
  • Combining board and batten with lap siding allows for creative architectural expressions, enabling homeowners to emphasize different features and improve overall curb appeal.

Siding Showdown: Beauty Meets Durability

Do you ever look at your home and wonder how you could revamp its exterior to look stunning and stand the test of time?

Or perhaps you’ve thought about how the siding on your house could better reflect your personal style while protecting your investment?

If these questions strike a chord, you’re in the right place.

In this post, we’ll explore two popular siding choices that many homeowners in Ashwaubenon, WI, and beyond are considering: board and batten siding and lap siding.

You’ll discover the unique benefits and distinctive styles of each to determine which siding might be the perfect fit for your home.

By the end of this read, you’ll have a clearer understanding of how these siding options can enhance your house’s functionality and aesthetic appeal, ensuring you make a siding installation choice that brings you pride and peace of mind for years to come.

Understanding Board and Batten Siding

A blue home with a board and batten siding style

Board and batten siding, with its rustic charm and vertical alignment, offers a distinctive look that can significantly boost your home’s curb appeal.

Here’s what you need to know about this popular siding style:

What is Board and Batten Siding?

Board and batten siding combines wide boards and narrow battens installed vertically, creating a layered effect that adds depth and character to the exterior of a home.

This rustic look has historical roots but has been adapted for modern use, offering both aesthetic and functional benefits.

  • Historical Context: Originating as a practical solution for sealing gaps in wood plank exteriors, board and batten siding has been a staple in American architecture, particularly in rural settings.

  • Architectural Benefits: The vertical lines of board and batten can make a home appear taller, enhancing its presence while providing a timeless look that appeals to many homeowners in Ashwaubenon, WI.

Material Options for Board and Batten

Choosing the right materials for your board and batten siding project is crucial for both the longevity and appearance of your home exterior.

Here’s a rundown of the most common materials used:

  • Wood: Offers a classic and authentic appearance but requires more maintenance due to susceptibility to rot and pests.

  • Fiber Cement: Durable and low maintenance, fiber cement siding such as Hardie Board offers excellent durability and is resistant to fire and termite damage.

  • Vinyl: A cost-effective option that is easy to install and maintain, available in various colors and textures to mimic more expensive materials.

  • Engineered Wood: Brands such as LP SmartSide combine real wood’s beauty with increased moisture and decay resistance.

Installation and Maintenance of Board and Batten

Proper installation and regular maintenance are key to ensuring your board and batten siding lasts through the harsh weather conditions of Wisconsin.

  • Installation Tips: Ensure that each board is properly sealed and aligned. Use a moisture barrier behind the siding to protect the structure of your home.

  • Maintenance: Regular inspections and potential painting or sealing every few years will keep wood and engineered wood options looking fresh and prevent deterioration from exposure to elements.

By selecting the right materials and adhering to maintenance guidelines, board and batten siding can offer a long-lasting and visually appealing option for homeowners seeking to upgrade their home’s exterior.

Understanding Lap Siding


Lap siding, a popular choice for residential homes, is known for its horizontal planks that overlap to create a water-tight exterior.

This is the style of siding that you most commonly see on traditional homes in Wisconsin.

What is Lap Siding?

Lap siding, often seen in traditional American homes, adds a classic aesthetic while protecting against the elements.

The overlapping boards help shield homes from moisture and debris.

  • Types of Lap Siding: Includes Clapboard, Dutch Lap, and Shiplap, each offering a unique profile and shadow line that enhances the home’s exterior.

  • Architectural Enhancement: This style not only protects but also elongates the appearance of a building, giving a sleek and streamlined look.

Material Choices for Lap Siding

The choice of material can significantly impact the durability, maintenance, and appearance of your lap siding.

Here’s what you need to know about the materials available:

  • Wood Siding: Provides a natural and timeless look but requires regular maintenance to prevent rot and deterioration.

  • Fiber Cement Siding: Offers excellent durability and low maintenance, resistant to fire and pests, making it a superb choice for varying climates.

  • Vinyl Siding: Affordable and easy to maintain, available in a range of colors and textures to suit any home style.

  • Engineered Wood: Strikes a balance between the beauty of real wood and the resilience against moisture and pests, offering a long-lasting siding solution.

Installation Tips for Lap Siding

Proper installation is crucial for maximizing the lifespan and effectiveness of lap siding.

Here’s how to ensure it’s done right:

  • Alignment and Sealing: Each plank must be precisely aligned and sealed to prevent water ingress, which could lead to structural issues.

  • Professional Installation: Considering the expertise required, particularly for materials like fiber cement, hiring professionals is advisable to ensure the siding is installed correctly and securely.

With a range of styles and materials to choose from, lap siding can be tailored to meet the aesthetic and functional needs of any home.

By understanding the properties of each material, Ashwaubenon residents can choose a siding option that provides beauty, durability, and a protective barrier for their homes.

Design and Aesthetic Impact: Board and Batten Siding vs. Lap Siding

close up of lap siding

Choosing the right siding not only protects your home but also plays a crucial role in its overall aesthetic and architectural harmony.

Let’s explore how both board and batten and lap siding can influence the look and feel of your home, making it stand out in the Ashwaubenon neighborhood.

How Siding Influences Home Aesthetics

Both board and batten siding and lap siding offer unique aesthetic advantages that can transform the appearance of your home:

  • Vertical vs. Horizontal Lines: Board and batten siding adds a dynamic, structured look with its vertical lines, which can make a home appear taller and more stately. Conversely, lap siding, with its horizontal patterns, tends to stretch the home’s appearance, making it look broader and more grounded.

  • Texture and Shadow Play: The battens in board and batten siding create natural shadows, adding depth and interest. Lap siding’s overlapping boards achieve a subtle texture that plays with light and shadow differently, offering a softer, more cohesive look.

Architectural Compatibility

Matching the siding to your home’s architectural style is key to creating a cohesive look:

  • Modern and Rustic Designs: Board and batten siding is often associated with rustic farmhouse designs but can also complement modern homes due to its clean lines and simple form. Lap siding is incredibly versatile, suitable for everything from traditional to contemporary home styles.

  • Enhancing Features: Both siding types can be used to highlight architectural features. For instance, board and batten can emphasize the height of gables or towers, while lap siding can accentuate the length and sweep of a ranch-style home.

Selecting the appropriate siding involves considering both the functional aspects and the aesthetic impact on your home.

By understanding how these siding styles can enhance your home’s exterior, you can make a choice that not only protects but also beautifies your living space.

Practical Considerations: Board and Batten Siding vs. Lap Siding

When choosing siding for your home in Ashwaubenon, WI, practical considerations such as cost, maintenance, and material durability are as important as aesthetics.

Here we’ll break down these aspects to help you make a well-informed decision about your siding options.

Cost Analysis

Understanding the financial implications of your siding choice is crucial for budgeting both initial outlays and long-term expenses:

  • Material Costs: Wood siding generally costs less per square foot than fiber cement but may lead to higher maintenance costs over time. Fiber cement and vinyl offer excellent durability with less upkeep required, potentially saving money in the long run.

  • Installation Costs: The complexity of installation for board and batten siding might be higher than for lap siding, which can affect labor costs. Professional installation is recommended for materials like fiber cement to ensure longevity and performance. Follow the links to learn more about shiplap siding cost and board and batten siding costs in Ashwaubenon.

  • Maintenance Costs: Wood siding may require regular treatments such as painting or sealing to protect against moisture and decay, whereas vinyl and fiber cement need less frequent maintenance.

Environmental and Climate Considerations

Choosing the right materials for the local climate in Ashwaubenon can prevent premature deterioration and enhance your home’s energy efficiency:

  • Weather Resistance: Fiber cement and vinyl siding are known for their resistance to severe weather, making them suitable for the fluctuating climates of Wisconsin.

  • Energy Efficiency: Properly installed siding can improve your home’s insulation, reducing heating and cooling costs. Materials like fiber cement are particularly effective at insulating against both cold and heat.

Longevity and Durability

Selecting siding that stands the test of time without fading, cracking, or buckling under environmental pressures is key to a cost-effective investment:

  • Life Expectancy: Vinyl and fiber cement siding can last up to 50 years or more when properly maintained, compared to wood, which may require more frequent replacement if not meticulously cared for.

  • Warranty Offers: Many siding materials come with warranties that cover everything from material defects to color retention, providing additional peace of mind about the durability of your investment.

By taking these practical considerations into account, you can choose a siding solution that not only enhances your home’s exterior but also aligns with your financial and maintenance capabilities, ensuring lasting satisfaction with your home improvement project.

Combining Board and Batten and Lap Siding

Board and batten siding used in combination with lap siding on a home

Integrating both board and batten and lap siding on your home can create a visually striking and unique exterior.

This approach allows homeowners to enjoy the best of both worlds by utilizing the distinctive features of each siding type to enhance architectural details and add curb appeal.

Strategies for Using Both Styles in Different Sections of the Home

Combining these two popular siding styles can not only elevate the design of your home but also tailor it to fit the landscape and architectural style prevalent in Ashwaubenon, WI:

  • Aesthetic Balance: Use board and batten siding to emphasize vertical elements like gables or taller sections for a dramatic effect, while lap siding can cover broader, horizontal areas to visually stretch the home’s facade.

  • Functional Design: On sections of the home that are more exposed to weather elements like wind and rain, consider using the siding type that offers the best protection in those conditions. For instance, lap siding may better shield against wind-driven rain due to its overlapping design.

Examples of How to Combine Board and Batten with Lap Siding

Here are some practical implementations that have successfully combined these siding types:

  • Using Different Siding Styles for Different Levels: You can install board and batten siding on the second story and lap siding on the first, creating a textured look that highlights the home’s architectural complexity.

  • Accent Features: Another common approach is to use board and batten siding as an accent around windows and doors, which provides an appealing contrast to the lap siding on the main sections of the exterior.

By thoughtfully combining board and batten and lap siding, you can enhance the character of your home, making it stand out in your neighborhood while still reflecting your personal style and meeting your maintenance expectations.

This method not only adds depth to the design but also allows for creative expression through your home’s exterior.

Discover How Urban Exteriors Transforms Homes with Expert Siding Solutions

Choosing the right siding involves more than just picking a material; it’s about finding the perfect balance between aesthetics, durability, and maintenance.

Whether you opt for the classic appeal of board and batten or the streamlined look of lap siding, each choice can significantly enhance your home’s curb appeal and value.

Urban Exteriors specializes in bringing these visions to life, ensuring that every siding project not only meets but exceeds your expectations.

With our expertise, you can seamlessly blend the rustic charm of board and batten with the elegant simplicity of lap siding to create a unique and inviting exterior.

Ready to transform your home’s exterior into a stunning showcase that stands out in your community?

Fill out our contact form today, or give us a call to discuss how we can bring your siding project to life with precision and style.

Let Urban Exteriors be your partner in making your dream home a reality.